How to Get Useful Feedback on Your Website Design
Asking "what do you think of my site?" almost always gets you vague answers like "looks nice" or "the colors are off". Useful feedback comes from asking the right people the right questions, and then knowing what to do with the answers. This is how to get it.
Before you ask anyone
- Write down what the site is for. One sentence: who it is for and what you want them to do. Every piece of feedback gets judged against this.
- Decide what kind of feedback you need. First impression, usability, copy, visual design or code are different questions. Asking for "everything" gets you a little of each and not much of any.
- Fix the obvious problems first. Broken links, missing images, typos and a page that fails on mobile will eat everyone's attention. Run a quick check yourself before you spend other people's time.
Who to ask
- People who match your audience. A plumber's site should be tested by people who might hire a plumber, not only by designers.
- Other designers and developers. They spot spacing, hierarchy, accessibility and performance issues that regular visitors feel but cannot name.
- Someone who has never seen the site. You only get one first impression from each person, so do not waste it on people who watched you build it.
Questions that get useful answers
- "After five seconds on the home page, what do you think this business does?"
- "Find out how much it costs and how to get in touch. Talk me through what you are doing."
- "What almost made you leave?"
- "If you had to remove one thing from this page, what would it be?"
- "Was there anything you expected to find and could not?"
Give people a task, then watch and stay quiet. Where they hesitate tells you more than what they say afterwards.
How to read the feedback
- Look for patterns, not single opinions. One person disliking a color is taste. Three people missing the contact button is a problem.
- Separate the problem from the suggested fix. "Make the logo bigger" usually means "I could not tell whose site this is". Solve the real problem, which may not be the logo.
- Do not argue or explain. If you have to explain the design, the design is not doing its job yet. Say thank you and take notes.
- Rank by impact. Fix what stops people from doing the main task first, then what slows them down, then what is just a matter of taste.
A simple template for asking
When you post your site for review, in a community or by email, include:
- The link, and whether it is live or a staging version
- Who the site is for and its one main goal
- The two or three specific things you want opinions on
- Anything you already know is unfinished, so nobody wastes time on it
A clear request gets specific answers, and specific answers are the ones you can act on. Ask again after each round of changes: the second round of feedback is usually the most useful one.
Comments
Post a Comment