Opinions/Suggestions please

[ivcho]

Hi guys..

I've done 4 versions with different colors, elements, positioning etc.

which one do you like and why?

http://www.bgidesign.com/clients/JAN/JANMCNAB
http://www.bgidesign.com/clients/JAN/JANMCNABV2
http://www.bgidesign.com/clients/JAN/JANMCNABV3
http://www.bgidesign.com/clients/JAN/JANMCNABV4

Thank you in advance

[JR]

i like the layout of 1 but i like the green colour shcme because it goes well with the picture that is underneath the header. However the text in the header does need antialiasing :classic: good work

[smoseley]

I like the navigation in 2, but try to make the heirarchy more discernable (by colors or text size)

i like the layout in 3

[kirbtastic]

i like the navigation in 2..doest overlay on of the content, but i like the color schemes in 3 and 4. blues just seem to look more professional

[splufdaddy]

I like the navigation in #2 as well, and I like the layout of 3 and 4. One thing though, is that the text color in #3 is hard to read on my CRT. I was positive it was a light gray until I moved it over to my LCD, where it looked ok. It's probably a combination of the different hardware and settings, but I'd reccomend black text on the white bg (if that's not what you have)

[zionlocke]

i like 3

[TheGAME1264]

I'd go with 3 for a pair of reasons:

1) The colour scheme in 3 most closely resembles that of the Prudential logo (and you might as well take advantage of any offline brand identity that already exists).

2) The left-side navigation looks better on the site.

I'd suggest putting a 1px blue border around the outside of the submenus (and possibly between the elements themselves) to distinguish it from the content (I find the white BG tends to blend in with the content too much.)

Beauty work, eh?

[ivcho]

wow.. so many good posts

Thanks guys!..
I'll consider it all and show updates later on..

[SupraPorsche]

I like the layout on #4 but I like the green more.

[SupraPorsche]

Nevermind what I said earlier! #2 is the bomb